Identify the actual problem

Ask whether the concern involves crawling, indexing, relevance, reporting or conversion. A traffic decline is a symptom with several possible causes. A request for “more backlinks” is a proposed tactic, not a complete diagnosis.

Migration timing, URL changes and affected page groups can provide a useful starting point. Do not infer a cause from one screenshot or a single ranking.

Qualification worksheet

AreaEvidence to request appropriately
TimingWhen the change or concern began
ScopeAffected pages, markets and site sections
Change historyMigrations, redirects or content changes
MeasurementAvailable reports and their limitations
AccessWhat review access can be provided safely
ExpectationWhether the buyer accepts uncertainty and evidence-based work

Do not ask buyers to post credentials or private analytics data publicly. Move sensitive review into a suitable agreed process.

A response to a migration request

Hypothetical example: a store says search visibility dropped after moving platforms. A useful reply explains that redirects, canonicals, indexability and reporting should be reviewed before concluding why visibility changed.

Offer a defined migration review if the context permits. State its deliverables and limitations. Do not promise a ranking position or recovery date.

Disqualifiers and measurement

Reject requests for fabricated links, deceptive practices or guaranteed rankings. Also check whether the scope and access permit meaningful work.

Measure accepted diagnostic projects and viable engagements, not only SEO-related mentions. Keep project qualification separate from claims about search outcomes.